View Full Version : A noir Hero's journey?
DoubleIT
12-07-2008, 05:08 AM
Any examples of a heros journey in a modern film noir setting? Has it ever been done (well)?
Often in a hero's journey the act 1 setting ( the kingdom / whatever) is no longer interesting to our hero as he begins his journey to another land. In a noir the stylized world of our (anti) hero is of major importance. A bit of a contradiction combining the two? Any examples?
mario_c
12-07-2008, 08:47 AM
The key if I'm not mistaken, is the hero traveling from his 'home' to discover his mission in another land. Closest I can think of is Blade Runner, where the Harrison Ford character has to sort of infiltrate the world of the synthetic humans to bring them back to justice. Does that make sense?
If it's a spiritual journey, it's easier: in Chinatown, Gittes is perfectly content to stalk cheating wives for money and have his shoes shined. But the Mulwray case drives him out of his content bubble and motivates him to help Mrs. Mulwray at risk of his own life.
clockwork
12-07-2008, 10:22 PM
I think most noir stories include an element of travel/infiltration of a foreign land even if that foreign aspect is just people and their behaviour rather than a separate physical place, like mario's examples above.
Did you see Brick (http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0393109/)? That was a noir detective story meets high school teen drama. There was no travel to another land for the hero but he did travel into an underworld that he had little knowledge of before. It certainly fits into the category of film noir with a modern twist.
I guess the distinction to make here is whether you're talking about an actual journey to another place or something a bit more metaphorical.
whistlelock
12-09-2008, 01:33 AM
It may help to think of it no as Man Goes on a Journey, but a Stranger Comes into Town. Where the stranger is the noir hero.
The noir detective usually upsets the balance of someone else's life more than having their own lives unbalanced (although they are, of course).
DoubleIT
12-10-2008, 03:03 AM
This was a great help thanks guys.
Chinatown and Bladerunner are fitting examples. I also like the 'stranger comes into town' idea. That wasn't my initial take on how to work the story although it may add an interesting twist.
vBulletin® v3.8.5, Copyright ©2000-2012, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.