PDA

View Full Version : Would anyone like to take a look at my manuscript?


Linx
05-31-2007, 07:37 PM
I want to get a complete strangers opinion on my finished manuscript. Here is the synopsis:

Max Carlson is a brilliant existentialist, with deeply intuitive philosophies on life, love, and the general banality of the world. He's also a self loathsome, masochistic drug addict with severe social anxiety. He drinks too much, sleeps with too many women, and pops pills to cope with his own misinformed and judgmental views of everything around him. He is the epitome of wasted potential and he knows it.

Watch as Max struggles to transition from an angst filled teen to a responsible adult, while making all the wrong choices. Dropping out of college to work at CensusPlus, a local call center in his small run of the mill town, he embarks on a journey most of us will never experience.

Losing himself in disassociative drugs, sexual affairs and an angry inner-dialog Max stumbles through his life violently destroying the last bit of hope he has for succeeding. His own desperation and negativity seem to be the only chance he has for survival, but can Max change what his life seems so destined to become? Is there a chance to save what's left of his world before it's too late? Will Max discover that living is worth more than dying, and just what he has to do to breathe again?

I have it copyrighted so I am not afraid to send people the full version, I only want a couple of people to read it, hopefully long time members. Please, if your interested let me know!

Julie Worth
05-31-2007, 07:59 PM
I scanned through your first five chapters, and I'll say that it's good that you wrote this, to get it out of your system more than anything. But it's not publishable, in my opinion. You might want to post the first chapter in "share your work," as most people here prefer not to go off site.

Linx
05-31-2007, 08:10 PM
I scanned through your first five chapters, and I'll say that it's good that you wrote this, to get it out of your system more than anything. But it's not publishable, in my opinion. You might want to post the first chapter in "share your work," as most people here prefer not to go off site.


Thank you for your input, but I was looking for a more indepth response, such as WHY it's not publishable? Thanks!

Lindo
05-31-2007, 08:21 PM
I can't understand why anybody would not want to "go offsite"... this is the internet:there's no "here" here.

For what little this might be worth to you, I just read your precis and would have absolutely zero interest in reading this thing.

A question might be: who would be your target readership for something that sounds so negative and sordid?

I think the other poster here said it very well, and diplomatically: it's good to drain stuff from one's system. It's not uncommon for writers to go through a couple of catharsis novels before doing one that would be of greater interest to others.

Good luck

Linx
05-31-2007, 08:26 PM
A younger generation, the way the world seems so negativly attuned, with all of the "emo kids" running amuck, it seems self loathing has taken on a new meaning.

Why would anyone want to watch Fight Club? Or read any of Chuck Palahuniaks books?

To each there own, I do appreciate the input as it gives me an idea of what to expect from a publisher/agent point of view.

Julie Worth
05-31-2007, 08:27 PM
I can't understand why anybody would not want to "go offsite"... this is the internet:there's no "here" here.


The "share your work" section is password protected, and doesn't show up in search engines. And by posting there, the writer is giving tacit approval to quoting the material and critiquing it for others to see.

Linx
05-31-2007, 08:30 PM
Thank you for pointing me there, I posted the first five chapters of my book there.

Even if this thing never sells it was an eye opening experience and I would like to self publish a 100 copies for my own personal reasons.

I think its worth a read, because its not completely negative - it has a positive, well developed ending.

it shows a lot of what teenagers go through, struggling with a drug addiction and growing up - more often than not we like to pretend that we live in a perfect little world and stuff like this doesnt happen. But it does - a lot.

Anne Lyle
05-31-2007, 08:33 PM
There's a forum here specifically for requesting beta-readers:

http://www.absolutewrite.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=30

I haven't read your work - it's really not my kind of thing - but I'm guessing Julie may be referring to point 8 on this list (scroll down a little way). It might not be true of you, but a lot of agents and publishers are going to assume it.

http://nielsenhayden.com/makinglight/archives/004641.html

Either that or it's simply that you're unlikely to attract many readers with such a down-beat story. Most folk don't want to wade through 300+ pages of misery on the off-chance that the protagonist will pull himself together at the end of it all.

Linx
05-31-2007, 08:37 PM
haha - that list is great.

I agree, I just felt that it was a story worth telling.

Perhaps I am not in touch with reality :-/ haha

Anne Lyle
05-31-2007, 08:46 PM
Why would anyone want to watch Fight Club? Or read any of Chuck Palahuniaks books?

I assume it's because Chuck has something to say about the state of modern society. Wouldn't know, since again he's not my thing. Or Brett Easton Ellis. Still, it takes all sorts...

Devil Ledbetter
05-31-2007, 08:50 PM
Why would anyone want to watch Fight Club? Or read any of Chuck Palahuniaks books?
Linx, I did a brief crit for you. Just so you know, I LOVED Fight Club.

Linx
05-31-2007, 11:33 PM
Linx, I did a brief crit for you. Just so you know, I LOVED Fight Club.


Oh I know - I am not complaining - I was just speaking my mind :)