SC Harrison said:
....they will tell you that vanity publishers charge a fee to produce a book....
Most do. The old-line vanity presses such as Dorrance and Vantage (are there others along that model?) also charge a HEFTY price for copies of the auhor's book, in addition to maybe tens of thousands of dollars up front. They get the fees coming
and going. But they are not POD, and do produce
some copies in an initial print run. (Might not bind them all, though ... been a long time since I looked into that.)
Anyway, I like the term
"crypto vanity publisher" for PA, as its fees are disguised. Plainly, however you label it, its business model is to make money by selling copies of the author's book TO the author.
Seems to me that the key here is to focus on the business model:
Selling to the author, not to the trade = vanity press.
What makes the business profitable for PA is jacking up the selling price of the books while enticing the authors to buy in quantity (hence the unending b.s. about how publishing works).
Personally, I think the focus on the copyright fee is missing the point. It is more pertinent that PA does not do the usual paperwork of a publisher, does not deposit the required two copies with the Library of Congress, does not obtain Library of Congress catalog information to go into the book. (By its own failure to meet the MANDATORY deposit requirement, PA demonstrates that it is
NOT a publisher. The case is open and closed by that measure alone.) The fee itself, in my opinion, is less important than those failures of normal publishing business practice. That the author pays the fee is more (in my opinion) of an artifact of the failure of PA to act like a real publisher. (I wonder whether anyone has queried the Library of Congress about PA's thousands and thousands of failures to meet the mandatory deposit requirement.)
I see the label "vanity in reverse" as confusing, if one views a vanity press as selling to the author rather than the trade. By that (reasonable, in my opinion) definition, there is no "reverse" about it. PA is a vanity press, plain and simple. However, the mechanics of its system tack the fees on at the end, not at the beginning (and deflect the copyright registration fee to the author). That, in turn, does allow some authors to see the book in print (two copies, plus the theoretical ability for other copies to be purchased) with only the out of pocket cost of the copyright fee AND with the nonmonetary (but real) cost of the seven-year rights grab. Hence (as costs are hidden or obfuscated), crypto vanity press.
PA is an equal opportunity exploiter, though, as it will as soon publish a good book as a bad one. Putting aside the question of manuscripts rejected only because quota has been reached for the day (or week, or whatever), one might suspect that most rejections are for authors who are recognized NOT to be candidates to buy enough copies of their own book (because they did not buy a first book with PA, or maybe because of other indicators that they will not buy and not wheedle enough friends and relatives into buying). PA plays the odds to reach the average sale of 75 or so copies per book, but presumably does what it can to improve the odds by filtering out the obvious non-purchasers.
Changing topics, here ... I wonder how many of the X thousand PA authors really had no intention of selling copies outside a small circle anyway. Some, of course (including some really bad writers, and probably some good ones) have higher aspirations. But I suspect that many have low expectations and are satisfied with the appearance of being a legitimately published author.
In any event ... while I appreciate your well reasoned views, it still seems to me that PA authors are not self-publishers
(they do not even own the publishing rights to their own books! nor the ISBN!), but rather are forced to cope with the failures of a very bad excuse for a publisher. They are stuck with a company merely masquerading as a publisher.
(FWIW, hanging around for a few years now with genuine, professional, competent self-publishers has influenced my views. I hate to see them lumped in with folks who are not in that business. It is an apples-to-lugnuts comparison.)
--Ken