The New Never-Ending PublishAmerica Thread (NEPAT)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Arden19

Registered
Joined
Mar 28, 2005
Messages
7
Reaction score
8
Location
Frederick, MD
I haven't been here in forever. But, I got news yesterday that I have to shout from the mountain tops!

I got paragraph 17'd yesterday. As of Feb. 15th, I am no longer a PA author! No strings attached, all rights are back to me.

YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 

SeanDSchaffer

Arden19 said:
I haven't been here in forever. But, I got news yesterday that I have to shout from the mountain tops!

I got paragraph 17'd yesterday. As of Feb. 15th, I am no longer a PA author! No strings attached, all rights are back to me.

YAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Hello,

I'm glad to hear you got out of your contract, but I am curious: my own contract has Paragraph 17 as a marketing and promotion paragraph. I take it your contract is different than mine.

Is the Paragraph 17 in yours similar to the Paragraph 24 in my own? The famous "When in the Judgment of the Publisher, the public demand for the work is no longer sufficient to warrant its continued manufacture...." paragraph?

In any case, congratulations. I wish you all the best.

smile.gif
 

PVish

Cat hair collector
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 24, 2005
Messages
1,641
Reaction score
263
Location
slightly off center
Website
peevishpen.blogspot.com
Shelagh's PAMB anouncement was short-lived

Sheryl Nantus said:
there's nothing yet on the PAMB.

I'm shocked.

You didn't look quick enough. She posted the debate URL on the PAMB Author's Lounge. Luckily I copied it early this morning:

Posted: Sun Feb 19, 2006 4:24 am** *Post subject: You are invited

As requested by James D. Macdonald, a debate has begun and can be viewed here:

http://s15.invisionfree.com/Debate/index.php?showtopic=4&st=0

The debate is one-to-one and may only be viewed.

Shelagh
_________________
Shelagh Watkins
Mr. Planemaker's Flying Machine
http://shelaghwatkins.co.uk/

Anybody want to bet that this got her banned?
 

TracySutterer & GaryRogers

Coffee Fanatics
Super Member
Registered
Joined
May 15, 2005
Messages
361
Reaction score
105
Location
South Dakota
Shelagh,

Two of your posts from the long thread on the private board have been pulled. Your post on the public board has been pulled.

What does this translate too? PA will not support you. You will not receive kudos from this company. In payment for your support you will be banned and PA will laugh at you while they push the 'ban' button. PA is a cruel and uncaring company. They could care less about you or your support.

Your 'friends' on that board are telling you not to pursue this debate.

What does that translate too?

None of your 'friends' will support you either. They don't have the guts to go against PA on this matter. Very soon, your 'friends' on that board will start shoving knives into your back so it will appear that they no longer associate with you. Your 'friends' will disappear one at a time. They don't want to be banned too.

This is the usual routine on the PA board. I've lived it many times. I can tell you all of this from experience. You may, of course, do as you wish with this matter, but I already know how this will all end. This drama has already been played out many many times.

Tracy
 

PVish

Cat hair collector
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 24, 2005
Messages
1,641
Reaction score
263
Location
slightly off center
Website
peevishpen.blogspot.com
If PA had good sense

If PA had sense enough to realize that they're going to have to pay out a humongous amount of postage to mail out statements to authors who have sold only one or two-or maybe no books—they'd start releasing books left and right. Just keeping up with 17,000 (or is it more now?) authors has to be a bookkeeping nightmare and a big expense in itself. If they send out 17,000 royalty statements first class (Do they send first class?), postage would be $6,630. Plus envelopes. And don't forget minimum wage for an envelope stuffer.

Hey, yo!—PA lurker-person who watches this forum: Suggest to the head honchos that they dump the authors whose books aren't selling, the authors whose books might be libelous or in violation of copyright/trademark, and anybody else who wants out. PA could save a bundle!
 

ResearchGuy

Resident Curmudgeon
Requiescat In Pace
Registered
Joined
Mar 26, 2005
Messages
5,011
Reaction score
697
Location
Sacramento area, CA
Website
www.umbachconsulting.com
Validation

A book that is published by the author has all the authority the author brings to it, but little else.
It is not quite that simple. A professionally self-published book--one that is published according to industry standards--has not only the authority of the author, but also the validation of pre-publication reviewers (quoted in jacket blurbs), trade reviewers (who have received and reviewed ARCs or bound galleys), and ultimately of trade channel book buyers (those who make selections for bookstores and other outlets) and ultimately of readers. Those are exactly the same kinds of validations available to commercially published books.

Depending on the type of book, such a book might also have the validation (or authority) of the writer of a foreword or introduction as well as authority conferred by acknowledgments. (Have you ever read the acknowledgements of a nonfiction book with an eye on what sorts of people had a hand in the development of the book? Some folks do.)

It is not black and white, self-published vs. commercially published, as self-publishing done right (that is, fully according to publishing norms) is, in all pertinent respects, fully equivalent to commercial publishing. (One learns that from working with successful, professional self-publishers, for whom the undertaking is a business--commercial publishing done on a small scale.)

Ok ... so, where does PA come in. First, it is NOT self-publishing (PA, not the author, owns the ISBN and manages the steps involved in reaching print). Second, it does not allow for real reviews. ARCs--"advance review copies" or "advance reading copies"--are not distributed to reviewers, and serious reviewers--for newspapers, magazines, trade journals--are generally not willing to review a book after it has already been published, although small-timers might. Third, the books are not available through normal trade channels. And of course PA is not commercial publishing in the normal sense (notwithstanding that the company is a commercial enterprise, a business). It is more of a facilitator of printing/binding services for individual authors.

PA pretty much offers all of the disadvantages of poorly done self-publishing and none of the advantages of well done self-publishing or of normal commercial publishing. It also has the added drawbacks of the seven-year rights grab, inflated list prices, limited availability, expectation that the author will purchase in bulk, and the whole "tone letter" milieu and self-referential, mutually congratulatory cult mentality that confuses its authors as to the nature of the transaction.

--Ken

P.S. If a vanity publisher is defined as one whose books are predominantly sold to or through its authors, then PA is a vanity publisher. Its business model is to sell books in bulk to the authors and to sell directly to individuals (primarily family and friends) whose contact information is provided to PA by the author. The model does NOT depend on normal trade channel sales, and in fact is designed to discourage such sales. Costs are recouped and profits made through inflated pricing combined with captive market (the authors directly and by proxy).
 
Last edited:

DeePower

Categories are irrelevant

It isn't how we classify the true business model of PA, it's how PA presents itself through its website and communication to its authors.

Below are some quotes from PA's rebuttal to a complaint I filed at the BBB.


Actually our business model is traditional...... Our business model is nearly identical to that of most major publishers.


Our marketing efforts are in line what is done by most major publishers.


We are not at all a “publish on demand” or POD publisher. We would have very little in common with any such publisher, vanity publisher, or subsidy publisher. You will find our marketing practices and business model to be closest to that of the largest major publishing houses.


Dee
 
Last edited:

Lady of Prose

Member - the "Sting Gang."
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 26, 2005
Messages
512
Reaction score
101
SC Harrison said:
The only marketing I've seen PA attempt has been associated with selling to their authors. Any positive news event, accomplishment by a fellow PA author or (supposed) shift in policy is used as an excuse to offer "special discounts" to authors. Even the New York Times PA Bestseller list was nothing more than an experiment to see how many books the authors would purchase.

Absolutely how it goes. And along with that, most of the authors are spending hundreds, if not thousands of dollars to promote their books that they bought from PA--giving them no weight at all in the "real publishing world," and also encourages more sheep to sign up for the slaughter.
 

SC Harrison

Dances With Hamsters
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
3,351
Reaction score
968
Location
Mid-life Crisisland
Website
www.freewebs.com
ResearchGuy said:
P.S. If a vanity publisher is defined as one whose books are predominantly sold to or through its authors, then PA is a vanity publisher. Its business model is to sell books in bulk to the authors and to sell directly to individuals (primarily family and friends) whose contact information is provided to PA by the author. The model does NOT depend on normal trade channel sales, and in fact is designed to discourage such sales. Costs are recouped and profits made through inflated pricing combined with captive market (the authors directly and by proxy).

Therin lies the problem, Ken. If you ask the average person who is not intimately familiar with publishing issues, and has never heard anything about the PA debate, they will tell you that vanity publishers charge a fee to produce a book. If you explain to them that PA doesn't charge an upfront fee (other than the $30.00 Copyright fee) and doesn't contractually require the author to buy anything, their first reaction is, "Sounds like a good deal to me."

This is a big reason why PA snares so many people, and one of the reasons they got me. They don't fit the classic definition of a vanity press, which is what (I believe) Shelagh is attempting to prove. I also understand your resistance to categorizing PA as self-publishing, and many of your arguments are correct. But, if you consider the facts that PA authors are responsible for 100% of the marketing of their book; they personally apply for the Copyright of said book; they set up web pages to promote their book and they (alone) pursue media exposure and/or reviews for their book, they are in practice self-publishing, they just don't know it.

I know you are a stickler for details, which is good. The problem is, PA has developed a business model which defies normal definitions. If we rule out everything they are not (which is what they count on), we come up with nothing understandable by the average person. While we may point out that the phrase "traditional publisher" was coined by PA, it is readily understood by Joe Public. On the other hand, the term "vanity in reverse" which was coined here, I believe, is not so easily understood by the public at large.

So, the question is: do we tailor our message to people who are already knowledgable in the field of publishing, or do we attempt to make the message understandable by all? I have a feeling the former are much less in need of a warning than the latter, but I may be mistaken.
 

ResearchGuy

Resident Curmudgeon
Requiescat In Pace
Registered
Joined
Mar 26, 2005
Messages
5,011
Reaction score
697
Location
Sacramento area, CA
Website
www.umbachconsulting.com
SC Harrison said:
....they will tell you that vanity publishers charge a fee to produce a book....
Most do. The old-line vanity presses such as Dorrance and Vantage (are there others along that model?) also charge a HEFTY price for copies of the auhor's book, in addition to maybe tens of thousands of dollars up front. They get the fees coming and going. But they are not POD, and do produce some copies in an initial print run. (Might not bind them all, though ... been a long time since I looked into that.)

Anyway, I like the term "crypto vanity publisher" for PA, as its fees are disguised. Plainly, however you label it, its business model is to make money by selling copies of the author's book TO the author.

Seems to me that the key here is to focus on the business model:

Selling to the author, not to the trade = vanity press.

What makes the business profitable for PA is jacking up the selling price of the books while enticing the authors to buy in quantity (hence the unending b.s. about how publishing works).

Personally, I think the focus on the copyright fee is missing the point. It is more pertinent that PA does not do the usual paperwork of a publisher, does not deposit the required two copies with the Library of Congress, does not obtain Library of Congress catalog information to go into the book. (By its own failure to meet the MANDATORY deposit requirement, PA demonstrates that it is NOT a publisher. The case is open and closed by that measure alone.) The fee itself, in my opinion, is less important than those failures of normal publishing business practice. That the author pays the fee is more (in my opinion) of an artifact of the failure of PA to act like a real publisher. (I wonder whether anyone has queried the Library of Congress about PA's thousands and thousands of failures to meet the mandatory deposit requirement.)

I see the label "vanity in reverse" as confusing, if one views a vanity press as selling to the author rather than the trade. By that (reasonable, in my opinion) definition, there is no "reverse" about it. PA is a vanity press, plain and simple. However, the mechanics of its system tack the fees on at the end, not at the beginning (and deflect the copyright registration fee to the author). That, in turn, does allow some authors to see the book in print (two copies, plus the theoretical ability for other copies to be purchased) with only the out of pocket cost of the copyright fee AND with the nonmonetary (but real) cost of the seven-year rights grab. Hence (as costs are hidden or obfuscated), crypto vanity press.

PA is an equal opportunity exploiter, though, as it will as soon publish a good book as a bad one. Putting aside the question of manuscripts rejected only because quota has been reached for the day (or week, or whatever), one might suspect that most rejections are for authors who are recognized NOT to be candidates to buy enough copies of their own book (because they did not buy a first book with PA, or maybe because of other indicators that they will not buy and not wheedle enough friends and relatives into buying). PA plays the odds to reach the average sale of 75 or so copies per book, but presumably does what it can to improve the odds by filtering out the obvious non-purchasers.

Changing topics, here ... I wonder how many of the X thousand PA authors really had no intention of selling copies outside a small circle anyway. Some, of course (including some really bad writers, and probably some good ones) have higher aspirations. But I suspect that many have low expectations and are satisfied with the appearance of being a legitimately published author.

In any event ... while I appreciate your well reasoned views, it still seems to me that PA authors are not self-publishers (they do not even own the publishing rights to their own books! nor the ISBN!), but rather are forced to cope with the failures of a very bad excuse for a publisher. They are stuck with a company merely masquerading as a publisher.

(FWIW, hanging around for a few years now with genuine, professional, competent self-publishers has influenced my views. I hate to see them lumped in with folks who are not in that business. It is an apples-to-lugnuts comparison.)

--Ken
 
Last edited:

LloydBrown

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jun 3, 2005
Messages
1,749
Reaction score
196
Location
Jacksonville, Florida
Website
www.lloydwrites.com
PVish said:
If If they send out 17,000 royalty statements first class (Do they send first class?), postage would be $6,630. Plus envelopes. And don't forget minimum wage for an envelope stuffer.

Yes, we've already determined that they're too stupid to use bulk mail for their royalty checks. They use first-class postage. At least--they did last time, and we know they read this board.
 

SC Harrison

Dances With Hamsters
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
3,351
Reaction score
968
Location
Mid-life Crisisland
Website
www.freewebs.com
ResearchGuy said:
Selling to the author, not to the trade = vanity press.

What makes the business profitable for PA is jacking up the selling price of the books while enticing the authors to buy in quantity (hence the unending b.s. about how publishing works).

Most new PA authors probably believe the same thing I did: the discounted book sales to authors are just an added benefit to help them in their master sales plan. Later on, they realize buying and selling their own books may be the only way they can make it work, due to the extremely high price and low discount level for retailers.

Unfortunately, this realization is often slow in coming, and the deceptive information from PA's website combined with the "well managed" feedback from fellow authors on the PAMB keeps them motivated just long enough to part with their money.

It may be a different form of the vanity press than people are accustomed to, but it is a vanity, nonetheless.
 

DeePower

Paragraph 17 as the basis for cancellation?

This is paragraph 17 of the PA contract, or at least one of the versions I have.

Sales promotion, advertising and publicity, shall be at the Publisher’s election and discretion as to the extent, scope and character thereof and in all matters pertaining thereto. The author agrees to actively participate in promoting the sales of said literary work in his home town area and elsewhere by making himself available to media interviews, book readings/signings, and other public sales promotion appearances.

How could this paragraph be used to terminate an author's contract? And why would PA use this paragraph? It just says that the author will be available for media interviews, books readings/signings, and other public sales promotion appearances. It doesn't say that the author will set up the readings or appearances. Or generate the media appearances. Or even market their book. Just speculating of course.

It also strikes me as curious as to why there are all these terminations.

Dee
 

Tilly

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
746
Reaction score
160
Location
UK
The spate of terminations is weird.

Perhaps Arden let PA know that they were no longer going to promote their book, and therefore wouldn't be available for the non-existant promotion from PA? That might be a technical reason why PA would use that clause. They use a clause of low sales when the author gets higher then average sales for a PA book.
 

astonwest

2 WIP? A glutton for punishment
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
6,561
Reaction score
1,206
Location
smack dab in the middle of nowhere
Website
astonwest.com
DeePower said:
How could this paragraph be used to terminate an author's contract?
Insinuating the author hasn't done enough to promote their book locally...
It gives them more wiggle room than imposing clause 24, which referenced insufficient sales numbers.

I have my own theory on why certain folks are receiving terminations...
 

DeePower

If that's the case any PA author who wants out

should immediately tell PA that they will no longer be available for any promotional activities.

Insinuating the author hasn't done enough to promote their book locally...

All the paragraph says is that the author has to be available for three things:

media interviews
book readings/signings
public sales promotion appearances.

If there aren't any set up, the author is in compliance.

This is not legal advice.


Dee
 
Last edited:

PVish

Cat hair collector
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Mar 24, 2005
Messages
1,641
Reaction score
263
Location
slightly off center
Website
peevishpen.blogspot.com
The Great Debate

Archiving this before it disappears over on the PAMB:

Can it be said that belief in the purpose of Publish America is nothing more than a blind commitment of the will? Are more than 17,000 writers wrong? Writers world-side whom have chosen Publish America to provide a vehicle for their ride to literary immortality? I think not.

The denial of PA as being good for authors of the world has less to do with facts and more to do with the bent of what a person is prejudiced to conclude. It is not the absence of evidence, but rather the suppression of it.

Of all the enterprises in which the human heart engages, none but religion lends itself more to abuse and manipulation than the activity of writing for publication—acceptance—validation.

Publish America antagonists cannot control their rage, demanding a sign that PA justify its business model but to PA’s credit rabid zealots are countered with quiet solitude. I think those questioning Publish America’s right to run their business as they see fit seem to retain selective sovereignty over what they allow as the purest method of publishing and what is not, an exercise in allegorical interpretation—believing in what one wishes, not what is.

I don’t care for the anti-PA published authors; they have their reward. I care for the unpublished, whom are merely pawns in a fruitless struggle. What a remarkable illustration of self-inflicted poverty, knowing it possible to hold one’s life quest, bound in hand, but opting instead for the wrapping.

Carl Baxter
Earth’s crammed with writers,
And every common bush afire with inspiration,
But only he who sees takes off his shoes,
The rest sit round it waiting to be called.
 
Last edited:

Sher2

Auroraless ExPAtriate
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
1,400
Reaction score
396
Website
freewebs.com
astonwest said:
I have my own theory on why certain folks are receiving terminations...
Would you care to share? I'm dying of Theory Overload here.
 

SeanDSchaffer

I have a question.

Most of you know that I have a book with PA. What most of you do not know is that I think I might be in violation of my contract.

According to Chapter 27, I covenant and represent that my literary work has not been published in book form before. I honestly feel stupid about all this, but several years before having gone with PA, I self-pubbed the work in book form. Back in 1998, I think, just after having copyrighted the work.

I've told PA about this; I'll see what they decide to do. But if I had just asked them about this in the first place, I would not have this problem now.


My question: what do I do beyond what I've already done? I must admit, I am concerned about this issue. I'm not the man I was back then, but still, the idea that this happened could tarnish my reputation as a writer and as an honest person.

It was a simple mistake, but I'm worried more will come of this than I had thought originally.


I don't know what to do.
 

Tilly

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
746
Reaction score
160
Location
UK
Sean, I don't think PA would dare take legal action against you, but if they get nasty, go to a lawyer. In fact, going to a lawyer anyway would probably be best.
I don't think anything that's happened in relation to PA will tarnish your reputation as a writer.
 

Savannah Blue

None
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 12, 2005
Messages
148
Reaction score
96
Tilly said:
The spate of terminations is weird.

Perhaps Arden let PA know that they were no longer going to promote their book, and therefore wouldn't be available for the non-existant promotion from PA? That might be a technical reason why PA would use that clause. They use a clause of low sales when the author gets higher then average sales for a PA book.

I did just that, Tilly. Wrote them a nice, polite little letter informing them that I would never purchase my own book nor would I actively promote my book, and further that I had attempted to contact each person on my mailing list and asked them to not purchase my book. I received a scalding 'tone' letter back from them. That was September of '04 and I'm still waiting to be released from my contract.

Hearty congratulations to each person to be released recently!
 

Tilly

Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 19, 2005
Messages
746
Reaction score
160
Location
UK
from the PA board said:
Can it be said that belief in the purpose of Publish America is nothing more than a blind commitment of the will?

I'm not sure PA has a stated mission that its authors believe in. But I think they believed PA when they were told their books were being given the chance they deserved.

PA books have no chance. You could have written the best book in the world, and no one but your friends and family and perhaps a few others will know about it. This is because of PA's policies, for example, over promotion (it won't do any) and returns (it has actually made it harder for PA books to be stocked by book stores through its bogus returns policy).

The deserve part interests me. I think the owners of PA really do think you and your work don't deserve a chance.

Are more than 17,000 writers wrong?

17000 authors clearly do not support PA. 17000 authors could well have believed PA when it says it's a traditional publisher, and not a POD.


Writers world-side whom have chosen Publish America to provide a vehicle for their ride to literary immortality? I think not.

You're not immune to being misled by living in another country.

The denial of PA as being good for authors of the world has less to do with facts and more to do with the bent of what a person is prejudiced to conclude. It is not the absence of evidence, but rather the suppression of it.

I honestly don't know what information or evidence the author thinks is being suppressed.

Of all the enterprises in which the human heart engages, none but religion lends itself more to abuse and manipulation than the activity of writing for publication—acceptance—validation.

<cough> hyperbole <cough>

There is plenty of abuse and manipulation of new writers seeking publication, who don't yet have the knowledge to defend themselves against POD companies saying they are a traditional publisher and not a POD.

Publish America antagonists cannot control their rage, demanding a sign that PA justify its business model but to PA’s credit rabid zealots are countered with quiet solitude.

I don't want a sign.
I want PA to be honest about what it is. I want it to either become a commercial publisher as it implies it is, or be honest that it's a POD.
PA can't counter the criticisms against it. They're true.

I think those questioning Publish America’s right to run their business as they see fit seem to retain selective sovereignty over what they allow as the purest method of publishing and what is not, an exercise in allegorical interpretation—believing in what one wishes, not what is.

If this was about 'purity' of publication, by which I think he means advocating commercial publication over POD, there would be a never-ending Lulu thread, or a never-ending Xlibris thread.

I don’t care for the anti-PA published authors; they have their reward.


I think by reward he means commercial publication.

I care for the unpublished, whom are merely pawns in a fruitless struggle.

For many, many writers, the struggle for publication is not fruitless. I'm guessing that this author believes that PA is his only chance, that he stands none with commercial publishers.

What a remarkable illustration of self-inflicted poverty, knowing it possible to hold one’s life quest, bound in hand, but opting instead for the wrapping.

If your life quest is to hold two printed copies of your book in your hands then...nope, I'd still recommend Lulu.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.