Was Bay ever going to be around for more than a year? GREAT pickup, but IIRC, it never looked hugely likely that he would be around long. And Ellsbury will be back - he's hardly damaged goods, so he definitely doesn't count as a failure. And there's Pedroia - or is he still around?
Tavares - Julian Tavares, the same one they got from the Cards?
Can't win 'em all. Maybe 'inconsistent' is the word... the loyalty to Papi and Varitek, possibly both well past their best, is staunch to say the least, whereas for some of the others, "it's a business". Derek Lowe - huge in 2004, gone. Look at him go now. But on the other hand, Bronson Arroyo? Hum. Potential is a funny thing.
He wasn't afraid to let go of some of the players from 2004 - big risk, and an emotional wrench, I'm sure. But they were back three years later.
For all that, it's not been a great couple of years, I agree. Even the Yankees don't get everything right, though, not by a long shot.
Epstein isn't afraid to make big calls. And the owners haven't flinched. Their reward is that, no matter what, their places in the Boston sports pantheon are assured, and Boston is a Sports Town.