I apologize for not coming back to the thread recently; it was a crazy busy weekend. Thanks to everyone who gave advice and shared their plans. I have a lot to say in this post, and it's going to look sort of like I asked a really vague question in the first post only to share what I really meant to refute everyone whose responded. But I swear my question only really came into focus for me after reading all the responses and thinking them over.
Several responses were along the lines of "just write the book" or "don't use planning to procrastinate." I don't think I'm stalled because I'm planning, and I don't think planning is necessarily foolhardy without a finished MS, even if plans change. I think my procrastination comes from some place else, and it manifests in a specific way (i.e., when I procrastinate, I'm watching TV. I find planning productive). I want to have a solid plan because I don't want to waste time. Yeah, yeah, I know taking four years to write a book sounds like a lot of wasted time. But not all of that time was just procrastinating. I'd started the book, but then put it on hold when I joined because I realized I needed to spend more time learning craft. So I wrote a lot of non-saleable material. After I felt more comfortable with my writing, I realized I needed to figure out some other things—what was my voice? What kind of author did I want to be? What kind of writing did I want people to think of when they heard my name? What category did I want to write in? Did I want to be a SFF writer or contemp?
I've gotten half my book written, but now I'm a bit stalled because of a plotting issue I need to figure out, but when I do, I think I can get the WIP ready for Beta in a few months. So it's not that I'm not writing in favor of day dreaming or plotting out my future instead of writing. It's just something I've done at the same time, and I wondered if anyone else gave this much thought to the career aspect of it.
And some other comments have been in the vein of, "Don't quit your day job." And I just want to assure everyone that I have a day job (and I'm the primary earner in my household) and I'm not planning to quit it until I can transition over to a writing career that provides a similar income and accounts for having to purchase insurance for my family. And I do understand that it can take many, many years to get published at all, let alone make a career out of it. So any planning and dreaming I'm doing, I'm totally doing from a place of stability and financial safety. And I'm grounded in reality. I'm not planning on getting rich next month or even next year or at all (I was disabused of that notion within weeks of joing the forum.
)
At the same time, though, I do believe in the power of positive thinking and visualization. I don't want to tell myself that it's most likely never going to happen and that this is all just a hobby because I really do internalize a lot of the things I tell myself. And I normally work better when I'm organized. I agree with a lot of self-help gurus that when you know what you want, it's good to make a plan (for as much as is in your control) and then actually take those steps. I want to be centered and have a vision for myself and my writing going forward, even if that plan doesn't always go as I'd epected—I can adapt.
Unimportant said:
1. Recognise that "published novelist who earns part/all of their income from writing" is more of a dream than a business plan. Writing is more often a hobby than a career.
All you wrote was good, helpful information. I wanted to comment on my rationale about the above step. Someone around here used to have this sig quote: "Treat writing like a hobby, you'll get hobby rewards. Treat it like a profession, you'll get professional rewards."
I want to be focused on my writing. I know it's a hobby at this point, but I want to treat it like a business. I want to take it seriously. I want to be prepared for things and I want to have a plan for building my author/series brand. I want an idea of the things I'm going to write and when I'm planning to write them (accepting that the market might force me to change the plan). I don't want to just write whatever I feel like and then realize that it's going to be the very odd duck in my otherwise similar-feeling backlist or that it's for a market that doesn't sell well (I'm category and genre versatile).
So all of that is the planning I'm talking about. So right now, I'm planning to write the first book in MG fantasy Series 1, and then move to the first book in MG fantasy Series 2. I've read from other industry pros, though, that writing only novels is a bit like putting all your eggs in one basket. It's a very slow-moving process, with generally small advances doled out over years, if there's an advance at all. (And that's another part of the planning; do I aim for an agent and large advances with big publishers, or do I go it alone at small presses with no advance?) So to make up for the slow/low advances, do I try to fill the gaps with articles or short stories for magazines? Do I self publish novellas (and how do I plan my branding in that space)? If I'm going to put up an author website or blog, should I start getting an idea of the kind of content I want to post to attract readers from my target audience? Do I diversify, as Aggy B said, and not focus solely on writing MG and branch off into YA or even adult contemp or cozies?
Cathy C said:
Absolutely! Writing is a career and you have to manage it or it'll run you over. The ms is part of it, of course, but a bunch is where to find readers and how to get the book into their hands. Mini-goals didn't really work for me. I'm a big picture sort of person so that I have to envision the whole goal before I can break it down into managable chunks. Like, I joined RWA...
The "planner" I'd looked at and linked to in my first post looks like it promotes mind-mapping. That's something my former day-job manager tried to teach me (loosely), but I never caught on until I looked at the planner. It seems like it would be a good way (for me) to organize mini goals based on big-picture items. "Get involved in my community" could have a lot of sub-goals, such as "post on AW three times a week," "Join SWCBI in my region," "Join a crit group," which I could further break down into smaller steps, actual action items.
Plan away, just don't lose focus on the one thing that's critical--the BOOK. The breathtaking worlds, the rich, touchable characters, the description that sucks the reader inside. Whatever your genre, learn what the readers can't live without and then give it to them.
While I understand and agree with what everyone's been saying about THE BOOK, I do feel like that's actually part of why I want a plan—because I need to build contingency for rejection into it. If this book doesn't work, if I'm not good enough yet, if the market just doesn't want this genre by the time I'm ready, I need to know where I'm going next so I don't flounder and mope about the death of this book. I'll work steadily on this book, but I want to know that this book isn't where I'm hanging all my hopes.
Jamesaritchie said:
Yes, but how many of them turn those plans into a real career? The last place I'd go to plan a writing career is a self-publishing board.
There are actually several on our self-pub board with decent sales—or at least the kind of sales even some of our trade published writers can expect. Others don't sell very well. As someone who wants to hybrid publish, I do think it's worth it to follow them and learn what they've done and what seems to work and what doesn't. There aren't any guarantees anywhere.
But it all comes down to Heinlein's Rules. Read what Robert J. Sawyer has to say about them, and believe him.
Thanks for the link. I've heard all of these rules at some point or another around here, but I've never seen them all in one place. I guess I'm stuck on Rule 2, right now, but I'll work through it. (Maybe I should work on a different story for a while.) Thanks for the link! And thanks for the breakdown of all the different things you write.
Aggy B said:
Diversifying what I write so I'm not constantly stuck trying to sell work in the same sub-genre. (Branding is useful, but only if it's producing sales.)
And that's one of the things I feel like I should at least start thinking about... what categories/genres can I write in? How should I separate myself as an author for each (same pen for MG and YA or different pens all around)? Which category and genre combinations are going to conflict (MG vs. NA erotica, for example)? Where should I be trying to publish them (like maybe MG for trade publishing because of the less substantial e-market, but YA for self publishing because of an audience for previous work)?
Anyway, everyone has been very helpful and the discussion has really bolstered my flagging hopes and gotten me focused on getting back on task. I really appreciate all the replies and how open everyone's been.