I have a friend who finished her first book about six years ago and it was considered a novella because it was just over 50,000 words. The second agent she queried wanted to read the whole manuscript but then in the middle of talking with her switched over companies and stopped all communication. She decided to give a copy to a few close friends to read and get opinions back then edited and added to the overarching story and the subplots. Her writing improved greatly during this time. After two years she started submitting again.
She is in the 2nd Draft of her third novel now, so it's not like she's a one trick pony. This first novel is largely allegorical and a little bit fantastic realism so she tries to pitch it as literary but has also pitched it as urban fantasy-realism/offbeat.
When she does get critiques back from agents she's only ever been told "you have a poetic style but it's unsellable." She's even asked if her query is the problem or character development. One agent did say that she had a slight issue with the first part of the book being more telling than showing but said that was a personal opinion. (The first half is a collection of interviews and recollections and news clips about the MC who is a pop icon).
Should she read between the line or is it because the novel is between genres?
She is in the 2nd Draft of her third novel now, so it's not like she's a one trick pony. This first novel is largely allegorical and a little bit fantastic realism so she tries to pitch it as literary but has also pitched it as urban fantasy-realism/offbeat.
When she does get critiques back from agents she's only ever been told "you have a poetic style but it's unsellable." She's even asked if her query is the problem or character development. One agent did say that she had a slight issue with the first part of the book being more telling than showing but said that was a personal opinion. (The first half is a collection of interviews and recollections and news clips about the MC who is a pop icon).
Should she read between the line or is it because the novel is between genres?
Last edited: