Then you get stories where the Girl was described as average at best looking or not that attractive yet somehow ALL the guys want her.
Well, some phenomena:
a) MC is a guy, a quarterback. He dates a dozen at a time.
b) MC is a guy, a super cute guy. He dates half dozen at a time (lacks QB's physique & stamina ^_^).
c) MC is an average guy, but has superpower (like mind control) or superhuman ability or porn star capability
d) MC is a girl, star cheerleader or Duke porn star material. Every guy (incl every teacher and school board member) wants to get into her pants. She scoffs at mere triangles.
e) MC is a girl, a super hot girl. -ditto- but she dates a few more cuz she has more time.
f) MC is a girl, an average Jo but has superpower (like mind control, yeah, cliche but you get the idea) or superhuman ability (no clue what that will be).
I, too, find conventional 1vs2 triangles too boring... even though I feel for jaksen's J and Putputt's B. I need to find a chance to write from J/B's POV.