Okay, I watched LLM yesterday and Homecoming today, and I think it was better to watch them separately because I spent the day in between thinking that I didn't think LLM was that bad.
Maybe I'm just so relieved to be out of the New New Directions rut the show got into. I hated Marley and Ryder, and I hated that every episode (not just some like in old-school Glee, but every single one) ended with the NND kids putting on a stage performance, half the time completely unrelated to whatever was going on in the episode, and most of those stage performances were also duets with the NY crew who outsang them completely. Unique was underused, and she and Blaine should have headed up the NND group, but for some reason didn't. I liked Kitty in the end, but have never forgotten that she started off so evil that Santana thought she was over the line.
First of all, I love that the hell that Rachel was living in was of her own making. She was always her own worst enemy, and ditching Broadway for TV because she thought it'd make her a bigger star, after ditching NYADA for Broadway because it was her dream? It absolutely makes sense for Rachel because when she's not winning, it's because her ambitions sabotaged her. Any normal person could see that the show being pitched at the end of last season would be a flop, but not Rachel because she always has stars in her eyes.
That first episode focused on the characters that probably hold the show together the most. Rachel, Kurt, Blaine, and a little of Mr. Shue and Sue. It was a good move to not bother with the New New New Directions students at all (even post-modern gay wasn't presented as a candidate in that episode). Putting Blaine back with the Warblers was a good move. He was always better with them anyway, and pitting him against Rachel and Kurt (whatever the ridiculous reasons are) is an excellent move, IMO.
In fact, I thought it was great that two of the 5 songs of the first ep were rival songs. The Warblers and Vocal Adrenaline were the ones that the show used to go to pre-competition to hear their performances, so it felt like a little bit of that old magic.
And I thought that ending that first episode with Rachel putting up the list (while singing a Rachel Berry anthem) was the perfect way to end that first episode.
---
For Homecoming, I didn't mind that the ND group was there, based on the excuse for the episode, although I think it's a little early for the "Class of 2012" to be returning for a reunion. I am a little wary of Rachel planning to call on them in the future, though.
The N[SUP]3[/SUP]D kids:
Love Jane. I was hoping she'd be with the Warblers to shake things up because I thought she did well with them, but I love her so I'm glad we'll get to see her at McKinley. Besides, I have to admit that all-men's a cappella is very nice to listen to.
Headphones Boy (no clue what his name is): I'm pretty sure that the headphones are there so he can sing Matt Nathanson's "Headphones" eventually, but since I identify with that song and with him, I'm cool with it. I was impressed with his voice so far, and it's a different sound than we've focused on in any incarnation of New Directions. I loved that the show tried to make you think the voice in the grates must have been post-modern gay/a jock in the shower, and then Sam even makes fun of that assumption.
Incest twins: Meh. They kinda remind me of the wannabe-NYADA-kids Rachel and Kurt met at the beginning of the third season. It will be interesting, though, with them being overachiever performers if Jane and Headphones Boy outshine them all the time. Imagine if Rachel hadn't actually been the star of the group, but still acted the same.
Though we haven't started glee meetings for real, I can just see how nicely this will work with Rachel and Kurt leading them. They'll get their time showing off, and it's teaching, but the other kids will also get their chance to sing for their lessons. Like, you had to roll your eyes a little when Mr. Shue sang, but with Rachel at the helm, it's really showing the kids something. However, if there isn't an episode where the kids have to remind Rachel and Kurt that it's supposed to be about the kids not the teachers, I will be surprised (since Mr. Shue had to be taught that several times and was, in theory, far less self-involved than Rachel).
Not sure how I feel about Blaine and Karofsky, but I am kinda happy to see Kurt and Blaine broken up and Blaine not being the one begging for them to get back together. I am so sick of whiny Blaine. I'm hoping being a Warbler gets him back to Awesome Blaine of season 2.
For both episodes, it's the same level of suspension of disbelief that has always been true for Glee, and I'm fine with that.