Making the First Book Stand Alone (Advice)

Parataxis

Obsessive Plotting Disorder
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 9, 2011
Messages
412
Reaction score
51
A few years ago I has an idea for a fantastic psychological thriller about teenagers who have super powers and the conspiracy that surrounds them. My premise was actually the "Big secret" of the story that the super powers come with an alternate personality that will slowly take over the main character and anyone else with powers However, I realized that there were enough complications and riffs on this idea that came after the reveal that if it was all going to be one book I would need to spill the big secret in chapter 3 or something which wasn't narratively sound. So the book was split into two books and eventually a trilogy.

Now I've reached the point where I've revealed my big secret (halfway through the first book) and I am thinking about where I want the ending to go. While I am not actively thinking about publication otherwise, I do know that first books of trilogies generally need to stand on their own and I am concerned that there really isn't a way to resolve the underlying conflict of the big secret in the first book. The ending as it stands right now is: The Bad guy's plot is foiled, but the love interest is taken over by his alternate personality, stabs the main character and leaves her for dead. She is rescued by the conspiracy who recruit her to work for them because her alternate personality seems more agreeable than normal. Just when she is feeling like there's no hope she receives a letter from her love interest saying that he isn't gone yet and that he's going to keep fighting and asks her to please be there when he comes back. It ends with her resolving to keep fighting.

While I am relatively happy with the romantic subplot ending, it still seems a rather obvious sequel hook. And, while a lot of the mysteries from the first half of the book (Who murdered these people? Why were these people after me? What's with the super powers?) are resolved, the lack of resolution for this huge thread of the narrative is making it all feel like a giant loose end.

I guess the question really is: How do you make a book stand alone when it's not? I know the story continues and while the ending I have really feels like an ending to me, it's bittersweet at best and not one I can imagine anyone would be happy with ending on "forever". Does anyone have any tips for making the first book stand alone?
 

Putputt

permanently suctioned to Buz's leg
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jul 10, 2012
Messages
5,448
Reaction score
2,980
From what you've described, that doesn't seem to be a problem to me. The baddie's plot is foiled, which sounds like the main story, so that's good...but it leaves the readers wanting more. I'd say that works. Reminds me of the endings of...everything else. :D
 

Sage

Supreme Guessinator
Staff member
Moderator
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 15, 2005
Messages
64,691
Reaction score
22,643
Age
43
Location
Cheering you all on!
To me, this sounds like a satisfying "hint of something more." Assuming that the Bad Guy is the big conflict of the book, I'd be satisfied with the defeat of him as the climax and resolution, and then the bittersweet loss of the LI but suggestion that he could be saved and that the MC could have a greater role dealing with the conspiracy are acceptable places to leave it or go forward.

ETA: Of course, it's hard to say specifically from a thread, so if you're still worried about it, get some betas and see what they say. And if you're not going to publish it, don't worry about it at all.
 
Last edited:

Lord of Chaos

Let Chaos reign
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Apr 12, 2010
Messages
189
Reaction score
17
Location
Durango, Colorado
I second the Beta reader suggestion because they would give you a better feel for whether you successfully wrap up the first book or leave too many loose ends.

A second idea, and this one is given without any idea how you've unfolded the story so take it with a grain of salt, is move the big reveal of the super powers into book two. That way, you can have a complete first stroy that doesn't open too many doors you can't successfully close in one book. If it isn't necessary for them to understand what the powers do in book 1, you can hint at it towards the end to set up the tie to book 2, without delving too deeply.

I know it's a movie, but think Pirates of the Carribean. First movie is wrapped up, the story concluded, and it can effectively end there without anything else and nobody will throw too big of a fit. But there were ideas that could be explored in movies 2 and 3, when the true depth of the story explodes onto the viewer and the first installment was only the opening salvo to see if they could handle the rest.