beezle said:Well, who can explain to me the evils of passive voice? What exactly is it? How can i avoid it? How will i recognise it?
Jamesaritchie said:Passive is a sentence wherein the subject has an action performed upon it. "The stream was crossed by John." An active is sentence is one wherein the subject performs the action. "John crossed the stream."
"The gun was fired."
"John fired the gun."
Look at the sentence to see who or what is performing the action. It's a matter of done to versus done by.
"To be" verbs, such as "was," do not always make a sentence passive, but they can be an indicator.
Make the subject of the sentence responsible for the action in the sentence, and you'll avoid passive sentences. And whenever possible, use active verbs instead of passive verbs. This alone eliminates most passive sentences.
maestrowork said:Sometimes, though, it is stronger to use passive voice, especially as a mystery, when you don't know who is doing things to the characters. Or when a "passive" mood is needed:
Mary was pushed over the roof by a stranger could be stronger than Someone pushed Mary over the roof.
The roads were closed because of the fire. The town was deserted.
katee said:Absolutely, Ray. Sometimes the passive is the best voice to use - but the rule that seems to be learnt is "don't use the passive" rather than "only use the passive if it's appropriate".
Hehe, and I wrote that sentence ("seems to be learnt") rather than ("xxx seems to learn") deliberately -- I wanted to distance the doers from the action and I wanted to emphasize the action itself -- so the passive voice was perfect.
I have three pet peeves about the passive - 1) it's gotten a bad name, 2) people seem to think that any sentence with a "to be" verb is passive and 3) people call it a "tense". The passive is a voice, not a tense (such as past), not a mood (such as subjunctive).
Jamesaritchie said:I think passive gets a bad name because it's usually bad writing. Not many use passive by choice simply because not many know how to tell passive from active.
IF you do know the difference, and make a conscious choice to use passive for a specific reason, it can be the best tool for the job.
....Snipped.
Absolutely! I only learnt about the passive because I was studying a second language - my schools didn't believe in teaching grammar and spelling. Studying linguistics at University taught me more about the differences between tense, voice and mood.Jamesaritchie said:I think passive gets a bad name because it's usually bad writing. Not many use passive by choice simply because not many know how to tell passive from active.
maestrowork said:I think I already showed some examples of when it would be a good idea to use passive voice.But here they are again...
zornhau said:IMvHO, these can be stronger in active voice, whilst still preserving suspense:
>Example: Mary felt a hand on her back, then she was pushed off the roof.
A hand pressed into the small of Mary's back. She twisted away, but the hand pushed. She tottered... fell... and the ground raced up to meet her.
>Example: Mary was knocked unconscious.
Something hard and heavy thumped into the side of Mary's head. Blackness washed over her.
I agree. As with so many other writing no-no's--the use of adverbs, for instance, or having a character see herself in a mirror--writing wisdom advises against it not because it's wrong, but because it's so easy to misuse. But it's also easy to go too far in the other direction. Like adverb-phobia, passive voice-phobia can cause writers to twist themselves into contortions to avoid ever using the word "was"--which can actually have the opposite effect to the one intended, making the writing stiff and artificial.katee said:The passive is a much maligned voice. I think, like any other grammatical construction, it definitely has its place in writing and it can be the most appropriate voice to use.
maestrowork said:Marilyn Monroe did not kill herself; she was murdered.
victoriastrauss said:... having a character see herself in a mirror--writing wisdom advises against it not because it's wrong, but because it's so easy to misuse.
loquax said:Reph, are you talking about using mirrors in first person here? Because I don't think the third rule applies to third person accounts. In first person, I don't really mind. Sometimes the gender isn't even important.
But otherwise I like to know what my character looks like.