- Joined
- Feb 12, 2005
- Messages
- 2,922
- Reaction score
- 3,044
- Location
- MD
- Website
- gorokandwulf.blogspot.com
Has anyone else seen this one? When I saw the ebook edition of Elmore Leonard's 10 Rules of Writing listed on Fictionwise Monday, I was really excited. I thought it was going to be an expanded version of the original article. I bought it before looking for reviews or before looking at the book in the store.
Whoopsie. It turns out that it's an illustrated gift book edition of the original article. Because of that, it's not doing well on Amazon. I agree with many of the points of the reviewers there, but I have to give some kudos for presentation. The rules are cool and useful, of course. And the presentation of the book is attractive. It is cheaply priced for a gift book (it's a small hardback that's under $15, and the ebook edition was even less). I also liked the illustrations. But... I still felt ripped off by this book. If I'd seen it in the bookstore, I would have known it was just an article turned into a gift book and said "Oh, how cute. Never mind." But because I bought it from an ebook site, I couldn't flip through the book, and for security reasons, you can't return ebooks. That'll learn me to look for reviews first.
MakingLight covered the orignal Ten Rules article, and I'll pick up more from those comments and reactions to the article than I did from the book itself. If you want to read the original rules, you can read them here. (You might have to register to read the original article as it's a New York Times article.) On the other hand, it might make a good gift for a writer, particularly one who is an Elmore Leonard fan. Especially if they haven't read the original rules yet.
Whoopsie. It turns out that it's an illustrated gift book edition of the original article. Because of that, it's not doing well on Amazon. I agree with many of the points of the reviewers there, but I have to give some kudos for presentation. The rules are cool and useful, of course. And the presentation of the book is attractive. It is cheaply priced for a gift book (it's a small hardback that's under $15, and the ebook edition was even less). I also liked the illustrations. But... I still felt ripped off by this book. If I'd seen it in the bookstore, I would have known it was just an article turned into a gift book and said "Oh, how cute. Never mind." But because I bought it from an ebook site, I couldn't flip through the book, and for security reasons, you can't return ebooks. That'll learn me to look for reviews first.
MakingLight covered the orignal Ten Rules article, and I'll pick up more from those comments and reactions to the article than I did from the book itself. If you want to read the original rules, you can read them here. (You might have to register to read the original article as it's a New York Times article.) On the other hand, it might make a good gift for a writer, particularly one who is an Elmore Leonard fan. Especially if they haven't read the original rules yet.