Has anyone read Graceling by Kristin Cashore?

xcomplex

Fantastic Fantasy!
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 10, 2009
Messages
490
Reaction score
17
Location
Canada
Website
www.arielemerald.blogspot.com
I didn't see any reviews on it here, so if you read it what did you think? Here is my review...It is also psted on my blog...

I just finished reading Graceling last night by Kristin Cashore. I have seen lots of great reviews on it, so I picked it up and it also seemed like it was based on the more medevil sword figfhting era, which my novel is based in, so I wanted to see what the hype was. This book was admired by a lot of girls my age and after reading it I can say, I am really not so sure if it would be loved by boys (Forgive me if it is, lol) and I really don't understand why it is rated PG 14. If you have not read the novel, keep in mind that this review contains spoilers.


My Rating: * * * (3 stars/5)

So I will start with a short summary, and then get to the point of my review. If you are interested in having your novel reviewed by me, feel free to drop me a comment. Anyways, the summary...Basically Katsa is a girl who can kill people with the nail of her small finger. She has a grace of killing. Graces in the novel are more like specialty talents that are portrayed when somebody's eyes change color at a young age. As niece of the king, she should be able to live a life of privilege, but Graced as she is with killing, she is forced to work as the king’s thug. She never expects to fall in love with beautiful Prince Po. She never expects to learn the truth behind her Grace—or the terrible secret that lies hidden far away . . . a secret that could destroy all seven kingdoms with words alone.



My Review:

Love the idea. That's why I bought the book, but to me the execution and plot was dull. Katsa is somewhat an annoying character. I know Kristen Cashore tried to make her a very strong female lead, but I found her to be very Mary Sueish at times and angry for no reason. Anger management, dude. Seriously. Her grace is a bit confusing to me and I find that if I wrote this I wouldn't call it the grace of killing but maybe of like fighting or something along those lines? Maybe strength? Because everyone has the ability to kill, its just the way she does it...She does though find out later that her grace is not killing, but survival. The fights were very swift and to me I found they were described too shortly. Like she just hit men with her boot and bam! Ten men down. What confused me was that how in the world she overcame graced fighters so easily.


Now, there were great things in the novel but let me continue my ramble...She is king Randa’s slave and when she meets Po, he tells her that she shouldn't be his slave. Ok, thinks Katsa, I’m going to go kill him if he doesn't let me leave. Randa fears her, for she can dodge arrows, but I am sure if he wanted her dead than he could arrow her down with a thousand or so men. I am sure it’s impossible to dodge that many arrows. So with Po who is the grandson of the stolen Lienid grandfather, she leaves to search why in the world the grandfather was stolen in the first place. Po lets her beat him up every day and I am surprised he hadn't gotten a hematoma from her punches to the head. I mean I was in a car accident and I hit my head....2 months off, brain bleed. Eeek! I think Po is a well described character, I liked him, but he takes allot of things that I really don't know if a real guy would take from Katsa. Actually he is probably the only one she is really nice to and I liked how she slowly evolved into a more humane girl throughout the novel.


Another thing, the whole giant back-story description of the kingdoms was confusing. I skimmed. It was like Wester, Nender, Ender, Blender and I was like what??? And all of those kings and queens and yikes! I think it would have worked better if it was weaved into the narrative. So anyways, she and Po leave to find why the grandfather was stolen. Their travel lasts forever and through that travel they get to know each other until, more than halfway through the novel, they find that king Leck stole the king and he is playing with minds. Did I mention Po (whose real name is Greening) is a mind reader? Oh, and I felt their romance was somewhat off and undeveloped...So they find Bitterblue who is running away and is the daughter of Leck. I think this could have been done better because a scene or two later, when Po sacrifices himself, Katsa kills Leck with a dagger. Easily. and I don't feel the defeat and victory that I should feel when an antagonist is killed. Of course they travel with Bitterblue to get to Leck (there is allot of travel) and when they get to Po's castle, guess who's there...Just guess...Leck! She kills him and they find Po who went blind and live happily ever after with Bitterblue as the queen.


Overall thoughts...I loved the idea. I enjoyed the read, but I thought there was allot of back-story, telling and not enough action to amaze me and engage me. Graceling didn't exceed my expectations but it served as entertainment and I think that it was a fun read overall. Katsa was interesting...Po was a very beta male I will do anything kind of person. So overall you should read it if you haven't! Cheers!
 

Lillie

practical experience, FTW
Kind Benefactor
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Jan 14, 2011
Messages
1,585
Reaction score
178
Location
Wales
I've read this. I got it out the library a few months back.
I don't have it any more so what I am writing is from memory

I enjoyed it on the whole. I thought the backstory was well filled out. I thought the back story was done quite well and I remember there being a fair bit of action. Arms being broken and such like.
The concept of the graces was well explained. I felt that I understood the whole business and it was worked well into the story.
The map helped me get my bearings with all the names.

Other things did not sit so well with me. Aspects of the story seemed corny and obvious. The young woman as expert assassin/warrior has been done to death too many times. The love story was just cheesy. So, they fell in love. I was neither surprised nor interested. Perhaps though that is just my age and jaundiced outlook on life.
I found the ending to be both a cop out and somewhat offensive. He goes blind. What a tragedy. Except it isn't because his grace (his super power) means he can still see. Even better than he could before. So in this way he gets all the sympathy and none of the disadvantages and difficulties of an actual disability. It left me feeling that the book had attempted to manipulate my emotions with a ruse. Sympathy had been garnered for a disability that would never really be a problem to him. I was as though the writer didn't have the knowledge or the bravery to follow through with the events she had started and make him really blind with all the problems that entails and instead had copped out with a nice magical cure for him.

On the whole I enjoyed it. It was better than some of the dross the library has offered up to me.
I wouldn't pay real money for it though.
 

trailerbride

Northern scum. Southern belle.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Feb 3, 2011
Messages
69
Reaction score
4
Location
Tejas
Website
pankhearst.com
I enjoyed Graceling enough to get Fire - a prequel of sorts. Fire is excellent, I think. A bigger book in just about every way. Though I have no idea which has more words.
 

Flint

Just believe. Then work your butt off.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 24, 2009
Messages
60
Reaction score
4
Graceling wasn't bad. I definately dug the magic system Cashore created, but the story was pretty standard fantasy fare. But even with that said it's still better than most epic fantasy out there. I preferred "Fire" much more.
 

Lauretta

In the fantasy word.
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Oct 2, 2009
Messages
2,452
Reaction score
750
Website
ciliegino.dallemieparti.net
I abandoned the book after 30 pages or so. Picked it up after reading all the great reviews. Got bored almost immediately, not worth my time.
 
Last edited:

pamelam

Registered
Joined
Dec 8, 2010
Messages
15
Reaction score
2
Location
Alabama
I absolutely loved Graceling. It had all the elements I adore--strong female protagonist, political intrigue, new fantasy twist with the Graces. I also liked that everything didn't wrap up neatly in the end. That book really resonated with me, enough so that I snapped up Fire as soon as it came out and liked that one even more. I'm anxiously awaiting the next book in the series.
 

Gary Jarvis

New kid, be gentle!
Super Member
Registered
Joined
Nov 16, 2010
Messages
122
Reaction score
19
Location
England
Something about Graceling made me fall in love with the book. I can see why people feel the way they do as mentioned above but for me it all just seemed to fit.

The fantasy system in place with Graces was superb IMO the extra ability power balanced of against a racial prejudice/jealously from non Graced. It was explained clearly and it was clear Kristine knew every detail about her system its limits and potentials etc.

I felt the one hit and down thing worked for me the whole point of her Grace when this is mentioned is that nobody has a Grace like it no fighter Grace was the same as her Killing Grace and a Grace making you the best at what you do would mean one hit is enough. Then the explanation of how she had been taught control though it was difficult made that back story work and give an insight into Katsa's view on life.

The love story for me whilst some consider cheesy just fitted perfectly for me. He had the right characterization and Grace that offset Katsa's personality weaknesses and gave him enough of an edge for her to find him a challenge.

I do agree with the blindness thing as mentioned though it did feel as either don't bother with it or go all out. I remember feeling almost devastated that he had lost his sight and that they would have to deal with it a cracking twist only for a deus ex machina kinda with him being fine almost. I guess for the age group it was targeted at (not me lol) this ended fitted better but I would have preferred one or the other.

Anyway just opinions from me.

P.S. Yet to pick up Fire but as people are enjoying it more will have to grab me a copy.

G