The Giver

CaroGirl said:

I just heard of this book by Lois Lowry and have read a small bit about it. I'd like to ask a question of anyone who's read it: What age is it appropriate for? I saw The Giver has been criticized for being inappropriate for children despite having won the Newbery Honour. My son is 10. Is he ready?

Click to expand...

The themes presented in The Giver are better appreciated by older kids, IMHO. In the school district here, they teach it in 6th grade, and I think that's too young. I really think, given the issues/themes/social commentary, it's better suited for like, freshman.

It's a FABULOUS book, though. Absolutely outstanding. Very thought provoking.

But not one I'd recommend for a 10-year-old. I'd recommend it for all adults, though.

Susan G.

I read it when I was fourteen, and felt I was much too old and I'd spoiled it by waiting so long.

I'd say ten is fine. There's nothing inappropriate or traumatizing that I could recall. However, a ten-year-old may not be able to grasp the meaning of the novel; then again, maybe they would. It really depends on the child.

I asked my daughter, 19 now, and she said she read it at age ten (4th grade,) and again in 7th-both as assignments. She then chose to read it again as a high school junior. She said it was appropriate at all three ages and each time she got something different from it.
My other four kids have all read it around 10-12 and it's popping up for them in their middle and high school years.
We all love it, at every age here, and we have a couple of copies floating around.

Caro, it's a pretty quick read-you're probably the best judge of whether it's appropriate for your child. And I bet you'll like it

Provrb1810meggy said:

I'd say ten is fine. There's nothing inappropriate or traumatizing that I could recall. However, a ten-year-old may not be able to grasp the meaning of the novel; then again, maybe they would. It really depends on the child.

Click to expand...

Some ten-year-olds probably wouldn't mind it. Great book, but traumatizing enough I wouldn't let my elderly mother read it.

The Giver by Lois Lowry

I bought the book after seeing that it was a Newbery Medal winner, an award which I had great respect for. I just read the book yesterday, and I have to say it didn't disappoint me. No, that's way understated. Almost from the moment Jonas became the Receiver, I was crying every page. Beautifully crafted, with a deep message. And the ending was awesome too.

I've read some criticisms that the book's symbolism is too heavy-handed, but I didn't feel that. It had just enough emotional power, just the right story, just the right plot. At first, the first impression I got after reviewing the novel was that it was a Christian allegory, but now that I think back I think the symbolism was more Buddhist than anything else.

Anyways, I think everyone should read it. It is certainly a great ride for children and adults alike.

Exir said:

I bought the book after seeing that it was a Newbery Medal winner, an award which I had great respect for. I just read the book yesterday, and I have to say it didn't disappoint me. No, that's way understated. Almost from the moment Jonas became the Receiver, I was crying every page. Beautifully crafted, with a deep message. And the ending was awesome too.

I've read some criticisms that the book's symbolism is too heavy-handed, but I didn't feel that. It had just enough emotional power, just the right story, just the right plot. At first, the first impression I got after reviewing the novel was that it was a Christian allegory, but now that I think back I think the symbolism was more Buddhist than anything else.

Anyways, I think everyone should read it. It is certainly a great ride for children and adults alike.

Click to expand...

Oh my GOOOOOOOODDDDDDD! I haven't thought about the Giver in so long. Easily one of the best books I've ever read. Ever. Expertly crafted, and unique. And disturbing. Really introduced me to ideas I'd never thought about before, like the value of uniqueness and the pain of human experience, which, in turn, makes us human.

Rep for bringing this up. Wow, what a nostalgia trip...

Definitely one of my favorites. A beautiful book that needs to be on everyone's bookshelf.

Umm...

I liked the story, but I was unsatisfied with too many things in it, including the ending that didn't seem to fit. *hiding from tomatoes*

I know many love the book, but I thought it was just "okay". Interesting, quick read, but not something I loved.

I loved this book! Of all the literature I had to read in my various English classes, only a handful really stood out, The Giver among them.

I think I was in middle school when I read it. It was powerful and disturbing even then; I'm not sure what my reaction would be to it now...

Bukarella said:

I liked the story, but I was unsatisfied with too many things in it, including the ending that didn't seem to fit. *hiding from tomatoes*

I know many love the book, but I thought it was just "okay". Interesting, quick read, but not something I loved.

Click to expand...

Shun the non-believer! Shun the non-believer!

The Giver was a great book! I read it for the first time back in 6th grade. I may have to go back and give it another read one of these days, because I'm sure there is a lot I missed the first time I read it.

I read this for the first time last November. I was pleasently surprised at how much I enjoyed it as I am not into dystopian novels. It was an interesting but quick read.

Amazing, amazing book.

I'm not sure how much kids get from it, but I read it as an adult and was blown away by it. So much to think about there!

Susan G.

I loved it as well. Read it somewhere around sixth grade iirc, and it was one of the few books that I literally couldn't put down. Very powerful stuff.

Be sure and read Gathering Blue and then The Messenger. The former is very good and the later, while not the best book I've read, brings it all together... sort of...

I remember someone going on about this book and i thought: 'what could be so great about it?'
And then i read it for my 8th grade english class. i finished the book that very night.
loved it! still one of my favorites. and whenever i see it in a library or book store - cannot help but read the section where he gets his assignment.

The Giver is wonderful classic children's literature that can also be enjoyed by adults. The themes are thought-provoking and uncomfortable and beautiful - the hallmark of a great story. I am glad that it is read in so many middle grade classrooms and rather irritated that it has been banned in others. The Giver is on the ALA Top 100 Challenged Books list (boo hiss!). Read a banned book everyone! It's the best way to feel criminal . . .

I read this book back in the fifth grade and had to write an extra chapter that resolved the cliffhanger ending and, if I'm recalling correctly, it wound up being pretty damn good.

Edit: After more than a year of casual browsing I've finally reached post #100 ~*wootles*~