So I went to a version of this workshop in Toronto yesterday and here’s my experience and my take:
1. The quality of the talks are only alright. I feel that if you’ve done your homework, you may not learn a lot of new things. It might be more useful to someone who‘s just starting the journey and haven‘t researched much yet? The agent panels are more interesting, and there’s one where they read people’s first pages and tell you where they’d stop. That is eye opening and I highly recommend submitting your first page to get some real insight. (I didn’t, but I will if I ever go again.)
2. Having said that, you do get the feeling that the panel depends on who the agents are. And comments should only be taken as their own individual opinion. As they say, it’s a subjective business.
3. I did a few pitches. Would recommend it too; it’s not as nerve-wrecking as I thought, and it gets better after some practice. I recommend it because a verbal pitch is a good experience to have. You get to look at your query in a different way, and it’s easier to spot where the flow and transitions are wonky as you ”tell” it verbally. I think the priceless part is that in face-to-face pitch you see the real time reaction of the agents and can see where you have gotten them interested/excited, and where you may lose them or have them do a double take. If you pitch more than one, you may even spot consistency in their reactions and that is great feedback to have.
4. As for pitches themselves, all of the agents/editors I spoke to were very nice. And seem genuine. There was one I didn’t really connect with, but I guess that’s ok and it’s also good to know too. I connected really well with the rest and did get full requests out of the pitches, although I will keep my expectations low after seeing some comments above. But I got the invitation to query one who is perpetually closed on QM too so it’s good.
5. Overall, it’s a good experience and definitely not a waste of money or time for a first timer like me. I’m not sure if it’s worth every penny I spent (it’s not exactly cheap after you add in all the pitching cost), and the quality of the talk is not as great as I hoped (also there are a lot of disruptions during the talks as people come and go for pitches. And you will also miss part of the talk if you have to go for your pitch, so it’s like, they don’t expect people to stay for the full talk anyway.)
6. My overall recommendation: know what you want out of it before deciding to go or not, research the agents and don’t sign up blindly, and practice your pitch.
Hope this helps!